One of the BIGGEST LESSONS TO LEARN AS A PARENT is that you NEVER, EVER, EVER, EVER, EVER, EVER, EVER THREATEN SOMETHING YOU WON'T FOLLOW THROUGH ON. Never, ever, ever, ever, ever say something you don't mean. Something like "If you don't listen to me then you will never have chocolate again." Well, it's obvious that is an empty threat.
At the store the other day I overheard a Mom with four small children tell her second oldest son that if he didn't behave then the cops would come take him away. Seriously Mama? Not only is she making cops bad guys (where hopefully kids feel they can trust them in emergencies) she is making a huge empty threat. Kids figure that out really quick. Like, the first couple times you don't follow through.
On Sunday we had Stake Conference. For those that are LDS you know that it is two hours of conference in the chapel with your whole family. Kids and all. And unfortunately for us it was at 1pm which is pretty close to nap time. I tried to make sure that we had enough games/colors/toys/snacks/etc. to keep them pretty busy for two hours, but Punkin (2) wasn't interested in anything but the snacks. After they were gone she got a little restless and decided to try dancing in the isle.
I quietly and firmly told her to come back into the pew. She ignored me, so the next time I said "This is your warning, if you don't come back then I'm going to take you home and you're going to take a nap. She decided to test my resolve and kept dancing around. So, I turned to Daddy and said "I need your keys because I need to take her home for a nap." Then I went to pick her up...well, she threw herself on the floor and started to whine, so I picked her up and walked out. Once we were outside she got happy and thought "Hey, I like it out here." But I walked her to the car and took her directly home. We did the naptime routine and she went down. Once we had started the naptime routine she realized that I was indeed very serious and didn't even fuss when I put her down for her nap.
Other times do not go so well. There is screaming and shouting. Usually they seem to scream more over the little things, oddly enough. Perhaps we're about to dish up ice cream after dinner and Precious (4) keeps bullying Punkin (2). Let's say she won't let her into the kitchen. I always give a warning first. (If/Then scenario) "If you don't stop bothering your sister, then you will not get any ice cream. This is your warning." If it continues then she looses the privilege to have ice cream. She will usually say sorry, sorry, sorry, and promise not to do it again, but she had her chance to stop. She deliberately was disobedient and disregarded my instructions. Privilege lost.
On really rare occasions, if I feel it's right, I will give a second chance with another warning. "Okay this time you can have you ice cream, BUT you better be nice to your sister or you will go to time out." Maybe I'll up the stakes a bit. I don't prefer to do this (like I said it's really, really rare), and here's why. First, of course I'm not really following through when I give her the second chance after her warning, and second because it actually takes more energy out of me. I have to monitor her to see if she's going to follow through on her promise and not bother her sister, and if she doesn't behave then she'll go to time out which is harder on her and me.
Now, for example's sake let's say I gave her the first warning about stopping or she won't get any ice cream. She doesn't stop and I tell her she won't be getting any ice cream. First she'll probably whine and cry, and I'll say something like "You made your choice. You chose not to be obedient and now you don't get your ice cream." I reiterate why she is getting the consequence so that the process and lesson sticks in her mind. Then, "Please stop whining or you will have to go into another room."
Here is another choice she is faced with. Will she calm down or keep it up? If she calms down she may go play and do something else. Later I may give her the option to earn back the ice cream. If she does a chore, or something especially selfless. Or on the other hand she might keep up her screaming.
At this point I usually take a quick mental inventory:
-Did she have a nap today? Or yesterday? Did she sleep enough last night?
-Did she eat enough dinner? Is it hunger that's making her so cranky?
-Did something happen earlier in the day that would have hurt her heart? Is that what's making her act out?
If so, then there's something deeper rooted that I need to understand from her so that she can feel better and start acting better. If I'm not sure if there is something that's hurting her heart, then I ask. "Why are you acting like this? Did something happen today that made you sad, or made your heart hurt?"
If I feel that something might be my fault (like I didn't make sure she ate enough, or sleep enough, or it's late at night), then I usually ease up on her. I have to take my own responsibility too.
In this case we'll say that she has no reason to be acting out and simply is throwing a fit over her consequence and she won't calm down. I give her the options, "You can either go into the other room and throw a fit, or you can go to time out." Then I follow through depending on her choice.
I didn't make it a habit to make sure and follow through until Precious was about 2 or so. I got so sick of "one more." You know, every parent says it. "One more. Just one more, okay?" then you hand over what is hopefully the last marshmallow (or whatever relevant thing) and they start to cry,
"Mooooore, just one mooooore!!!"
Then you say a little louder and firmer, "Okay last one, one more and all done okay?"
They smile sweetly and get one more. Then again...."One more. One more!"
"No, I already said one more, that means we're all done."
Crying, whining, gnashing of teeth...."NoooooooOOOOO! More!!!!"
"Okay, just ONE MORE and that's it!!!"
They smile through their dramatized tears and say "Okay, one more."
And on, and on, and on it can go until frustration boils over and I'll just wanna throw her in time out for whining so much and go somewhere I can't hear her anymore! Right?
I realized that "one more" to a child just meant more and more, perhaps just one at a time. So, I implemented "One more and all done."
We do baby sign-language with our kids. Not elaborately, just words that they really needed to communicate or understand on a day to day basis. "All done" is one of them. It's both hands in front of you palms up, then turn them so it's palms down. Really simple. So I would always hold up one finger, for "one more," then do the palms up-to-down for "all done."
It took A LOT of times being true to it before she understood that I wasn't kidding. I really meant what I said. It was tears and yelling, but that goes away after standing your ground the first 2-3 times. But stand your ground! Don't waiver! TRUST ME that it's easier to stick it out through the first time (even if it's hours of crying, even all day of crying) then to give in and try again, and again, and again. They'll know that it was hard for you, and they'll keep pushing you each time until they can get what they want. I have learned that kids WANT to know that we are a constant in their lives. At heart they don't want us to be pushover's. They don't know how to communicate that, and it's mostly in their subconsciousness. But I'll get into that in another post.
I noticed though, that when Grandma came to visit on one occasion, she didn't know about our "rule" (if you wanna call it that). Precious took full advantage of "one more" then "one more" etc, with Grandma, until I told her how it was at our house. Then Precious realized what had happened and stopped whining when Grandma didn't do "one more and all done" over and over anymore.
I always try to remember that if I'm not a consistent person, others (kids, adults, whomever) won't trust me and my word. I think that adults are even more used to giving chances again, and again, and again, but kids seem to learn pretty quickly and they will test you thoroughly. Kids will also model their parents. They have such keen eyes it's scary.
I was telling my husband a while ago that it's the biggest injustice and blessing that our kids will learn to do everything we do. Good and bad, bad and good. They watch our reactions to situations and will do what we do (for the most part). If they react badly because they saw us do it and then we tell them not to behave that way....well, they can smell hypocrisy like a shark can smell blood. From miles and miles away. And that ruins the foundation of belief they have in us. Being a parent is the most perfecting process anyone could embark on. No wonder God recommends it. ;) It's hard and worth it.
I hope some of this is helpful to someone. I think about parenting alllllllllllllllllllllllll the time, and it's nice to have a place to put my thoughts. So, let me know what you think. Was this helpful? Do you have any questions? Let me know your insights and let's all learn from each other.
Post in the comments or comment on FB :)
I wish you all the same thing I wish for me:
Clarity of mind so that we can do what is best for our children, and raise them the best we can in this world to become the best they can be.
~Crystal
At the store the other day I overheard a Mom with four small children tell her second oldest son that if he didn't behave then the cops would come take him away. Seriously Mama? Not only is she making cops bad guys (where hopefully kids feel they can trust them in emergencies) she is making a huge empty threat. Kids figure that out really quick. Like, the first couple times you don't follow through.
At a Love and Logic parenting course I attended there was a story mentioned where a Mother was at her wits end because every time she took her daughter shopping with her she wouldn't leave the play place, and if she dragged her away she would scream for hours until they would go home. The Mother was horrified and usually just left early because she didn't want to deal with the embarrassment of having a screaming, tantrum child in the mall. (If I remember right, she was a single mother)
One day she asked her good friend to park her car outside of the mall and wait for her call. When the Mother got to the mall she prepped her child by telling her that she could play at the play place for fifteen minutes, then she needed to behave and not scream and shout while they did their shopping. IF the daughter didn't cooperate then she would call her friend (she was a good family friend) to come pick her up and take her home for a nap.
So, off to the play place they went and when it was time to go shop (as expected) the daughter threw her massive tantrum. The Mother then called her friend to come and pick up her daughter and take her home for a nap. Since this was all expected the friend was already waiting in her car outside. She packed up the daughter and took her home, AND didn't let her play but put her down for a nap. The Mother enjoyed taking her time shopping. As you can imagine.
Every time from then on the daughter knew that her Mother was serious and would follow through on what she said, and she behaved when they went shopping. Of course the Mother had to KEEP following through on what she said as well. One time does not cut it.
On Sunday we had Stake Conference. For those that are LDS you know that it is two hours of conference in the chapel with your whole family. Kids and all. And unfortunately for us it was at 1pm which is pretty close to nap time. I tried to make sure that we had enough games/colors/toys/snacks/etc. to keep them pretty busy for two hours, but Punkin (2) wasn't interested in anything but the snacks. After they were gone she got a little restless and decided to try dancing in the isle.
I quietly and firmly told her to come back into the pew. She ignored me, so the next time I said "This is your warning, if you don't come back then I'm going to take you home and you're going to take a nap. She decided to test my resolve and kept dancing around. So, I turned to Daddy and said "I need your keys because I need to take her home for a nap." Then I went to pick her up...well, she threw herself on the floor and started to whine, so I picked her up and walked out. Once we were outside she got happy and thought "Hey, I like it out here." But I walked her to the car and took her directly home. We did the naptime routine and she went down. Once we had started the naptime routine she realized that I was indeed very serious and didn't even fuss when I put her down for her nap.
Other times do not go so well. There is screaming and shouting. Usually they seem to scream more over the little things, oddly enough. Perhaps we're about to dish up ice cream after dinner and Precious (4) keeps bullying Punkin (2). Let's say she won't let her into the kitchen. I always give a warning first. (If/Then scenario) "If you don't stop bothering your sister, then you will not get any ice cream. This is your warning." If it continues then she looses the privilege to have ice cream. She will usually say sorry, sorry, sorry, and promise not to do it again, but she had her chance to stop. She deliberately was disobedient and disregarded my instructions. Privilege lost.
On really rare occasions, if I feel it's right, I will give a second chance with another warning. "Okay this time you can have you ice cream, BUT you better be nice to your sister or you will go to time out." Maybe I'll up the stakes a bit. I don't prefer to do this (like I said it's really, really rare), and here's why. First, of course I'm not really following through when I give her the second chance after her warning, and second because it actually takes more energy out of me. I have to monitor her to see if she's going to follow through on her promise and not bother her sister, and if she doesn't behave then she'll go to time out which is harder on her and me.
Now, for example's sake let's say I gave her the first warning about stopping or she won't get any ice cream. She doesn't stop and I tell her she won't be getting any ice cream. First she'll probably whine and cry, and I'll say something like "You made your choice. You chose not to be obedient and now you don't get your ice cream." I reiterate why she is getting the consequence so that the process and lesson sticks in her mind. Then, "Please stop whining or you will have to go into another room."
Here is another choice she is faced with. Will she calm down or keep it up? If she calms down she may go play and do something else. Later I may give her the option to earn back the ice cream. If she does a chore, or something especially selfless. Or on the other hand she might keep up her screaming.
At this point I usually take a quick mental inventory:
-Did she have a nap today? Or yesterday? Did she sleep enough last night?
-Did she eat enough dinner? Is it hunger that's making her so cranky?
-Did something happen earlier in the day that would have hurt her heart? Is that what's making her act out?
If so, then there's something deeper rooted that I need to understand from her so that she can feel better and start acting better. If I'm not sure if there is something that's hurting her heart, then I ask. "Why are you acting like this? Did something happen today that made you sad, or made your heart hurt?"
If I feel that something might be my fault (like I didn't make sure she ate enough, or sleep enough, or it's late at night), then I usually ease up on her. I have to take my own responsibility too.
In this case we'll say that she has no reason to be acting out and simply is throwing a fit over her consequence and she won't calm down. I give her the options, "You can either go into the other room and throw a fit, or you can go to time out." Then I follow through depending on her choice.
I didn't make it a habit to make sure and follow through until Precious was about 2 or so. I got so sick of "one more." You know, every parent says it. "One more. Just one more, okay?" then you hand over what is hopefully the last marshmallow (or whatever relevant thing) and they start to cry,
"Mooooore, just one mooooore!!!"
Then you say a little louder and firmer, "Okay last one, one more and all done okay?"
They smile sweetly and get one more. Then again...."One more. One more!"
"No, I already said one more, that means we're all done."
Crying, whining, gnashing of teeth...."NoooooooOOOOO! More!!!!"
"Okay, just ONE MORE and that's it!!!"
They smile through their dramatized tears and say "Okay, one more."
And on, and on, and on it can go until frustration boils over and I'll just wanna throw her in time out for whining so much and go somewhere I can't hear her anymore! Right?
I realized that "one more" to a child just meant more and more, perhaps just one at a time. So, I implemented "One more and all done."
We do baby sign-language with our kids. Not elaborately, just words that they really needed to communicate or understand on a day to day basis. "All done" is one of them. It's both hands in front of you palms up, then turn them so it's palms down. Really simple. So I would always hold up one finger, for "one more," then do the palms up-to-down for "all done."
It took A LOT of times being true to it before she understood that I wasn't kidding. I really meant what I said. It was tears and yelling, but that goes away after standing your ground the first 2-3 times. But stand your ground! Don't waiver! TRUST ME that it's easier to stick it out through the first time (even if it's hours of crying, even all day of crying) then to give in and try again, and again, and again. They'll know that it was hard for you, and they'll keep pushing you each time until they can get what they want. I have learned that kids WANT to know that we are a constant in their lives. At heart they don't want us to be pushover's. They don't know how to communicate that, and it's mostly in their subconsciousness. But I'll get into that in another post.
I noticed though, that when Grandma came to visit on one occasion, she didn't know about our "rule" (if you wanna call it that). Precious took full advantage of "one more" then "one more" etc, with Grandma, until I told her how it was at our house. Then Precious realized what had happened and stopped whining when Grandma didn't do "one more and all done" over and over anymore.
I always try to remember that if I'm not a consistent person, others (kids, adults, whomever) won't trust me and my word. I think that adults are even more used to giving chances again, and again, and again, but kids seem to learn pretty quickly and they will test you thoroughly. Kids will also model their parents. They have such keen eyes it's scary.
I was telling my husband a while ago that it's the biggest injustice and blessing that our kids will learn to do everything we do. Good and bad, bad and good. They watch our reactions to situations and will do what we do (for the most part). If they react badly because they saw us do it and then we tell them not to behave that way....well, they can smell hypocrisy like a shark can smell blood. From miles and miles away. And that ruins the foundation of belief they have in us. Being a parent is the most perfecting process anyone could embark on. No wonder God recommends it. ;) It's hard and worth it.
I hope some of this is helpful to someone. I think about parenting alllllllllllllllllllllllll the time, and it's nice to have a place to put my thoughts. So, let me know what you think. Was this helpful? Do you have any questions? Let me know your insights and let's all learn from each other.
Post in the comments or comment on FB :)
I wish you all the same thing I wish for me:
Clarity of mind so that we can do what is best for our children, and raise them the best we can in this world to become the best they can be.
~Crystal


